Great Italian Food Trade

The independent information portal on Italian agri-food excellences

HomePet FoodUltima pet food, GIFT warns the distributor

Ultima pet food, GIFT warns the distributor

Dopo la denuncia all’Antitrust, il 22.10.18, la nostra testata mette in mora il distributore Unicomm (gruppo Famila) e informa la ASL competente sull’inganno del pet food a marchio Ultima di Affinity Petcare SA.

Pet food e bidoni

The market of  pet food in pochi anni è diventato la mecca di falsari e truffatori. Le ragioni sono essenzialmente due:

- Italian consumers, like their European counterparts, devote increasingly more resources to their pets. To the point that the market for food intended for them reached 2 billion euros in Italy (2017),

- the public control authorities have not so far carried out the necessary investigative activities. Also due to the serious delay of the Italian legislator in introducing a specific sanctioning regime. (1)

The labels of pet food  are therefore still found in a gray area, a ‘no man's land’ where illegality and cunning thrive to the detriment of buyers and honest operators.

The paradox is represented by the result of a recent study by the University of Padua, which reveals that 3 out of 4 products, from the 40 samples examined, are illegal. A serious scenario, which apparently has not led to any official control.

The feed labeling rules are indeed in force, yet they are systematically violated. (2) From this observation stems the intervention of Great Italian Food Trade, firstly at the Italian Competition Authority (AGCM, so-called Antitrust), now also against the Unicomm distributor and the competent ASL.

The Ultima of scams

Information on the label of feed must first of all be based on the general criteria of truthfulness (and demonstrability), transparency (i.e. non-ambiguity) and clarity of information. In addition to having to comply with the specific criteria provided for by the appropriate regulations. (3)

I Pet Food branded Ultima they are instead distinguished by the wide use of misleading images, where whole fruits and vegetables are depicted that are present in completely negligible amounts. 0.35% of apple or dehydrated carrot pulp, depending on the case. Rather than 0.15% broccoli or 0.01% dehydrated red fruits. Meanwhile, the consumer pays, falling into the deception of buying premium products.

Nutritional and health claims on feed are themselves subject to specific rules, not dissimilar to those provided for foods, in the basic criteria.

Ultima, however, reaches the height of the scam, nell’associare alle dosi ‘omeopatiche’ di ortofrutta i claim nutrizionali e salutistici ‘Frutta e verdura fonti naturali di vitamine, minerali e antiossidanti. Aiutano a rafforzare le difese immunitarie’.

Where Regulation EC 767/2009 – besides prohibiting the boast on feeds of curative properties or disease prevention – stipulates that claims related to the strengthening or safeguarding of physiological conditions (as long as not linked to pathological symptoms) must be objective and substantiated.

‘Labeling, advertising  and the presentazione degli alimenti o mangimi, compresi la loro forma, il loro aspetto o confezionamento, i materiali di confezionamento usati, il modo in cui gli alimenti o mangimi sono disposti, il contesto in cui sono esposti e le information made available about them through any means,non devono trarre in inganno i consumatori’ (reg. EC 178/02, article 16).

The  responsibility of the distributor Unicomm is linked to the failure to monitor the blatant violation of current rules by its supplier Affinity Petcare SA, as well as to involvement in the aforementioned violations through advertising of ‘Ultima’ products on printed promotional material distributed in its centers, on Famila branded posters.

‘Spetta agli operatori del settore alimentare e dei mangimi garantire che nelle imprese da essi controllate gli alimenti o i mangimi soddisfino le disposizioni della legislazione alimentare inerenti alle loro attività in tutte le fasi della produzione, della trasformazione e della distribuzione e verificare che tali disposizioni siano soddisfatte’ (reg. CE 178/02, articolo 17).

It's time to put things in order, withdraw illegal products from the market and stop deceiving consumers by applying the appropriate sanctions.

Dario Dongo

Notes

(1) On sanctions on feed labels, see articles  https://www.foodagriculturerequirements.com/approfondimenti_1/mangimi-le-sanzioni-per-violazione-del-regolamento-767-2009 e https://www.foodagriculturerequirements.com/archivio-notizie/pet-food-etichette-e-allegazioni-in-arrivo-il-decreto-sanzioni
(2) Cf. 
reg. EC 767/09

(3) Regarding nutritional indications, reference is made to the guidelines of the European trade federation Fediaf,  Code of Good Labelling Practice for Pet Food, on  http://www.fediaf.org/self-regulation/labelling.html

DARIO DONGO
+ posts

Dario Dongo, lawyer and journalist, PhD in international food law, founder of WIISE (FARE - GIFT – Food Times) and Égalité.

Related articles

Recent articles

Recent comments