Great Italian Food Trade

The independent information portal on Italian agri-food excellences

HomePet FoodPet food, 3 out of 4 illegal

Pet food, 3 out of 4 illegal

Pet Food for food intolerances with  animal proteins undeclared in 3 out of 4 cases, among the 40 samples examined by the University of Padua. A real scandal, curiously ‘escaped’ by the national press, as well as to the control authorities.

Pet food for food intolerances

The  Pet Food specifically formulated for the diagnosis and reduction of food intolerances in dogs and cats consists of wet and dry foods that stand out for the ‘exclusive’ formulation. Expressed with terms such as ‘mono-protein’ and similar.

The products in question should venire formulati mediante rigorosa selezione delle fonti di proteine. Al preciso scopo di consentire la diagnosi e il trattamento delle intolleranze alimentari negli animali da compagnia, grazie ad apposite ‘diete a eliminazione’.

The elimination diet is in fact carried out by limiting nutrition to a single animal protein source, and is recommended whenever an adverse food reaction is suspected. The logic is identical to that applied to humans, who also have suspected intolerant foods removed from their diet to observe the effects.

Single-protein foods for dogs and cats, the Padua study

The University of Padua ha di recente pubblicato, su BMC Veterinary Research, la ricerca ‘Undeclared animal species in dry and wet novel and hydrolyzed protein diets for dogs and cats detected by microarray analysis.’ (1)

The researchers have used a kit analitico volto a identificare le proteine animali, a raffronto con il DNA di 19 diverse specie. Su una serie di referenze di pet food presentato come monoproteico, in quanto destinato a diagnosi e trattamento di intolleranze alimentari.

Only 10 products out of 40 analyzed hanno rivelato avere un contenuto conforme a quanto dichiarato in etichetta. I ‘restanti’ 30 pet food – vale a dire, il 75% del campione esaminato (!) – è invece fuorilegge. Con le seguenti peculiarità:

– 5 products do not even contain the protein of the declared animal species (!)

– 2 labels are so vague as to make an evaluation of their meaning impossible,

– 23 foods labeled as single-protein instead reveal the presence of additional animal proteins, of different species than declared.

13 of the 14 brands analyzed  by the Padua researchers present at least one product labeled inconsistently with its actual composition. The presence of undeclared animal proteins was mainly found in dry foods. The most frequent undeclared animal protein sources are pork, chicken, and turkey.

‘Dietetic’ pet food, dangers and responsibilities. The roar of silence

To the Padua researchers goes the credit for having brought to light a very serious situation, considering both the extraordinary spread of infringements and the severity of the resulting dangers. 3 out of 4 foods currently sold on the Italian market expose vulnerable animals to the real danger of adverse reactions. Disease and death. (2)

The safety of  Pet Food for the diagnosis and treatment of food intolerances – as well as that of diet-therapeutic foods and those specifically formulated for celiacs, in human nutrition – must be carefully verified regarding its outcome for vulnerable categories of consumers. 

The presence of undeclared animal protein sources qualifica pertanto i prodotti monoproteici come mangimi a rischio, ai sensi del ‘General Food Law’. Ciò comporta il dovere, per gli operatori responsabili, di provvedere al ritiro commerciale immediato di tutti i lotti potenzialmente interessati, notifica ai Servizi Veterinari competenti, comunicazione pubblica del rischio con precisazione dei motivi del ritiro e codici di lotto coinvolti, distruzione delle merci salvo diverso ordine dell’autorità. (3)

The public control authorities have a duty to intervene, in turn, following news of the feed safety risk. Once the identity of the products analyzed by the researchers of Padua has been verified, they should immediately initiate inspections, sampling, and analyses. Ordering the corrective actions mentioned above, where the responsible operators have not already acted on their own initiative. In addition to communicating the crime reports to the competent Prosecutor's Offices.

The scandal is international, as it most likely also concerns the  Corporation that control the market. We await to learn their names and to see legality asserted, for once, also in the pet food sector. In criminal and administrative courts, remembering that for a couple of years now the - so far unprecedented - sanctions for incorrect labels.

To serious companies lo studio padovano varrà da monito, un segnale esterno di rischio emergente (cross-contamination). Sarà quindi utile disporre piani di verifiche analitiche sui prodotti. In ipotesi di esito positivo, analisi sulle materie prime in ingresso ed eventuale revisione del processo di qualifica dei fornitori, riesame dei pre-requisiti e dei punti critici di controllo.

Dario Dongo

Notes

(1)  BMC Veterinary Research (2018) 14:209  https://doi.org/10.1186/s12917-018-1528-7. Authors Rebecca Ricci, Daniele Conficoni, Giada Morelli, Carmen Losasso, Leonardo Alberghini, Valerio Giaccone, Antonia Ricci and Igino Andrighetto

(2) Moreover, intolerances in quadrupeds as well as bipeds can cause the development of diseases whose lethal outcome is delayed compared to the intake of the proteins the subject is vulnerable to

(3) Cfr. reg. CE 178/02, articoli 15 e 20. L’autorità potrebbe ragionevolmente autorizzare la ri-etichettatura dei prodotti in questione, quali mangimi di uso corrente, in ottica di riduzione degli sprechi (feed waste)

DARIO DONGO
+ posts

Dario Dongo, lawyer and journalist, PhD in international food law, founder of WIISE (FARE - GIFT – Food Times) and Égalité.

Related articles

Recent articles

Recent comments